26.9 C
Monday, September 28, 2020

Will We Ever Trust Machines with Healthcare Translation?

- Advertisement -

To those of us old enough to remember the days before the internet, machine translation seems like a miracle straight out of science fiction. Translation mechanisms that work perfectly have long been established in science fiction, from Star Trek’s universal translator to the Babel fish in Douglas Adams’ The Hitchhiker’s Guide to the Galaxy.

- Advertisement -

As such, many of us have expected that the pace at which technology has been evolving should mean that translation snafus and painfully awkward cross-cultural exchanges have become consigned to the history books.

And at first, it seemed Google Translate would fill that role. Or if not Google Translate, some other more sophisticated software. It especially seemed like a boon for healthcare translation, where medical professionals are often tasked with the difficult process of communicating complex medical terminology and concepts to someone who doesn’t speak their language.

But will machines ever be able to replace a good translator? Will we ever get to that glorious future where translation mishaps and cultural barriers become a thing of the past? Let’s take a look at whether machines can ever really take over medical translation.

The Supposed Promises of Machine Translation Services in Healthcare

Machine translation is a fast-growing industry. In fact, Grand View Research stated that machine translation had a $433 million global market size in 2016, and was expected to continue to grow exponentially from there.

Meanwhile, in 2015, Modern Healthcare reported on a new app from a company called Canopy, heralding it outright as the tech that would once and for all “break down language barriers for patients, doctors.” The company was started by a first-generation Chinese-American who saw firsthand how difficult it was for his Chinese-speaking family to access healthcare.

This followed a 2012 report from the Agency for Healthcare Research and Quality, which stated that patients with limited English language skills have longer hospital stays and are at higher risk of infections, pressure ulcers, read missions and falls.

So an app that would smash through the language barrier, possibly even supplanting language specialists entirely, felt like a dream come true. One doctor even switched to the app after frustration with his usual over-the-phone interpreting system that left him with convoluted conference calls.

However, the app worked best for quick conversations geared toward gathering basic information. More in-depth conversations still needed phone interpreters.

Machine Medical Translation Fails

While machine translation has come on leaps and bounds in recent years, with neural networks and deep learning changing that way that machines process language to more closely mirror the human brain, it’s still a far way off from being able to replace professional translators. This is especially the case in the medical industry, where a machine medical translation hiccup can damage or even cost lives.

- Advertisement -

Medical mishaps due to human translation errors are nothing new. In 2010, NBC reported on a doctor who removed the wrong kidney from a Spanish-speaking patient as a result of a communication failure. In 2015, the Daily Mail reported on a British expat who had a needless double mastectomy in Spain after a translation problem.

On a more humorous note, Sputnik News reported on medical mishaps with Google Translate while British fans were at the World Cup in Russia this year. A man needed a tetanus shot after a dog bite and was using Google Translate to talk to the nurse. Google Translate somehow handled what the nurse was saying as “What kind of pizza did you have for dinner?” Thankfully, somehow, the man did manage to get his shot and survive to tell the tale.

Stories like these show how necessary it is to not blindly rely on machine translations. A single mistranslated word or phrase can lead to the unnecessary loss of body parts.

Why Machines Haven’t Quite Caught Up to Medical Translation Needs

For a bird’s-eye view of just how wrong Google Translate has been, there was a study conducted in 2014 that reviewed the accuracy of Google Translate in medical communication. The results were frankly depressing.

The study, published in the BMJ, translated 10 common medical phrases into 26 different languages. Only 57.7 percent of the translations were correct. The highest percentage of correct translations went to Western European languages, yet even those still only boasted 74 percent accuracy.

Some of those translation mishaps were incredibly serious. In Swahili, “Your child is fitting” translated into “Your child is dead.”

Although the study is from 2014, Google Translate still makes some pretty large gaffes, as highlighted by the World Cup story above.

Perhaps Gülay Eskikaya, an English/Turkish interpreter, said it best in a 2013 editorial for The Guardian: “Machines can only translate words and not meaning and will be unable to grasp concepts, abstractions or cultural references. Ultimately, machine translation fails to differentiate between the language of a literary masterpiece and a car manual, a United Nations convention and a text message. To the machine it’s one and the same.”

Since machines still can’t quite comprehend the nuance of human language, we’re a long way off from other uses like translation of medical forms and records. There are also more difficult aspects of translation, like multilingual typesetting, that call for the skills of graphic designers as well as translator. Suffice it to say, it looks like we’ll need bilingual staffing, over-the-phone interpreting and on-site interpretation for the foreseeable future, without question.

Author Bio:

- Advertisement -

Louise Taylor is head of content for Tomedes, a company that provides professional translation services in 90+ languages to clients all over the world. She has been covering a wide variety of translation and language topics for over five years.

Healthcare Translation
  • Save
- Advertisement -

Disclaimer: This article is purely informative & educational in nature and should not be construed as medical advice. Please use the content only in consultation with an appropriate certified medical or healthcare professional.

Editorial Staffs at Healthtian, A team of Writers.
- Advertisement -

Trending Now

6 Ways Internet Marketing Will Benefit Your Cardiology Practice

When you are running a cardiology practice, you are no longer just a cardiologist – you are also an entrepreneur. And every business needs...
- Advertisement -

Skin Rashes: Causes, Symptoms and Effective Home Remedies

Skin rashes are common skin problems experienced by millions of people worldwide; it is characterized by a visible change in the color...

Atis Fruit: 10 Health Benefits of Eating Sugar Apple

Sugar apple (Atis fruit), is the Annona squamosa fruit belonging to the natives of West Indies and to the tropical Americas like Peru, Mexico,...

Spider Bites: Symptoms, Treatment & Identification

Spider bites in the United States are often annoying but they are rarely fatal. If a person gets bitten by a black...

Enlarged Clitoris: Causes, Treatment and Symptoms

The clitoris is simply a female sexual organ located slightly above the urethra, a section where urine is released from the female body. A...

8 Majors Types of Bongs – Which One Strikes You

One of the best ways to consume cannabis is to smoke it straight from a bong. Bong offers a better way to enjoy your...

How to De-worm Yourself Naturally?

Parasitic or intestinal worms are behind many health challenges people face; they can cause a lot of problems including digestive problems. Some common types...

How to Increase Sodium Levels in Your Blood?

Levels of sodium in the blood is often a misunderstood topic and it is extremely necessary that we as individuals understand the meaning and...

7 Types of Disability and Examples

For disabled people life is a lot different than the rest of us. They don’t lead normal lives like we do and need assistance...



Nurture yourself with health tips, wellness advice, and more.

- Advertisement -

Related Posts

Sepsis (Septicemia) – Causes, Symptoms and Treatment

Sepsis is a severe and life-threatening condition caused by the body’s response to infection, which leads to severe damage to tissues and organ failure. Although...

Echinococcus: Symptoms, Causes and Treatment

Echinococcus is the infection that is caused by a parasitic tapeworm from the Echinococcus genus. Echinococcus can affect humans by a few types of...

Doppler Ultrasound: What is It Used for?

There are various types of ultrasound and of the popular ones is the Doppler Ultrasound. A doppler ultrasound is a special kind of ultrasound...

10 Parasites That Could Be Infecting You Right Now

It's likely that you’ve heard some people calling other parasites. But have you ever wondered what parasite is? In simple terms, it’s an organism...


Please enter your comment!
Please enter your name here

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

Healthcare Translation
Copy link
Powered by Social Snap