UK and Germany Build Consensus Over ‘heat-not-burn’ Products


Women Celebrating #nobraday 2019 on Social Media (Pics)

Today is #nobraday so our team will scout social media and bring you tweets and posts across social media...

Common (and Not-so-common) Plastic Surgery Procedures

What was first regarded as strange is now the norm for many people and for a diversity of reasons....

Twin Pregnancy: 10 Weird Signs You’re Carrying Two Babies

Think you’re carrying twins? You might be right—twins are on the rise. Find out what your pregnancy signs have...

Top Medical Alert Systems For 2020

Medical alert systems are monitoring systems that make it easy to request help in the case of a medical...

Eating Vaginal Discharge and It’s Health Benefits

For many people, vaginal discharge is a sign that a woman is ready and willing to have sex. Vaginal...

Do You Get Sick After Getting the Flu Shot? Here Is Why

This is the period of winter and Harmattan. Yes, it is the holiday period, but it is also the...

Anklet Charms and Hot Wives What Do They Mean?

Women all over the world love to accessorise. From putting on necklaces to wearing makeup and buying the latest...

Sugar in Watermelon: How Much and Health Implications for Diabetes

Watermelon is a delicious fruit, but have you ever wondered if there is so much sugar in watermelon? For...

The 4 Health Dangers of Sewer Gas

Most people take their water and sewer lines for granted. These pipes carry our waste, so we don't have...

A Few Reasons Why Its OK to Go Braless

Having a bra on for long hours is one of the most uncomfortable things that a lady has to...
- Advertisement -

Government advisory panels in both Germany and the UK have independently concluded that ‘heat-not-burn’ tobacco devices do pose health risks to users. However, they did find that such products were markedly less harmful than traditional cigarettes.


Germany’s Federal Institute for Risk Assessment (BfR) revealed in October that, after studying the Philip Morris-made IQOS, intake of carbonyl compounds such as formaldehyde and acetaldehyde is reduced by 80 to 90 per cent. The BfR also concluded that the emission of volatile organic compounds decreased by 90 to 99 per cent.

“We can confirm for these substances that tobacco smoke contains a significant reduction of pollutants,” added Dr Frank Henkler-Stephani who supervised the study.

Those figures have now been backed by findings earlier this month from independent Committee of Toxicity of Chemicals (CoT) in the UK. The CoT studied both the IQOS and the British American Tobacco-made iFuse and found that users are exposed to between 50 and 90 per cent fewer ‘harmful and potentially harmful compounds’ found in traditional cigarettes.

The difference in percentages was largely down to the nature of the two products in question and the temperatures at which they heat tobacco. ‘Heat-not-burn’ devices warm tobacco to a temperature high enough to create a vapour but not smoke.  The IQOS heats tobacco to approximately 350C, while the iFuse reaches just 50C. Tobacco is burned at around 800C in a conventional cigarette.

However, while reporting their findings to Public Health England, the CoT also revealed the devices produce ‘a number of compounds of concern’, some of which can cause cancer.

They also stressed that giving up smoking all together remained by far the safest option. Philip Morris International welcomed the findings. “We believe that smoke-free alternatives, including heated tobacco products like IQOS and e-cigarettes, have significant potential to be less harmful than cigarettes and can play an important role for smokers and public health,” said a spokesman for the company.

Nevertheless, the BfR did have concerns. While they acknowledged that ‘heat-not-burn’ products offered a less harmful alternative to current smokers, it may be offset by non-smokers taking up the product. Philip Morris International countered this by emphasising that their advertising for the IQOS revolved around ‘a new way to enjoy tobacco’ rather than attracting non-smokers.

The IQOS and iFuse also fit neatly into the policy of harm reduction being heavily pursued in both the UK and USA in the battle to reduce smoker numbers. The BfR, meanwhile, was wary of making health recommendations off the back of their research.

“We would expect this substantial reduction in pollutants to affect health risks,” said Dr Henkler-Stephani. “Nevertheless, recommendations are problematic because the emissions of tobacco heaters are still mutagenic.”

The BfR will continue their research into 2018 : they recently published another study focusing on HnB in the May issue of the Archives of Toxicology wich « confirmed reductions of relevant toxicants by about 80-99% » .  « The strongly reduced HPHC levels in the emissions of the analyzed HNB device are likely to reduce toxicant exposure » the study went on.

They were not alone in encountering limitations. The CoT claimed there had been a ‘marked difference’ in the data provided by the two manufactures, while there was also a lack of independent information available on both products. They also admitted there was not as much real-world data on which they could base their findings as they would have liked.

Both reports are at odds with research from the University of California, San Francisco, which found that ‘heat-not-burn’ products are almost as bad for health as conventional cigarettes.

Ultimately though, the BfR and CoT results are being seen as positive steps for ‘heat-not-burn’ products representing a viable alternative to traditional tobacco smoking.


This article is for informational/educational purposes only. Healthtian does not provide medical advice, diagnosis, or treatment, read more.

- Advertisement -


Please enter your comment!
Please enter your name here

- Advertisement -


What is Zoonotic Diseases? Causes and Prevention

If you live in an environment where you’re constantly around animals, or spend a lot of time around them,...

The Biology of Membrane Receptors

Membrane proteins exist in the cell membrane and allow for the communication between the cell and the extracellular space. The use of recently developed...

Things You Need to Know Before Starting Your Chest Workout

It wouldn’t be surprising to think that all women fancy men who have a finely carved chest. A man’s hotness is ideally defined by...

Want To Lose Weight This Year? Check Your Sleep Habits

2019 is here and countless Americans have resolved to lose weight in the new year. But where to start? Many will adopt fad diets...

Houseplants Can Purify the Air in Your Home

I really love house plants. To me, houseplants add nice texture to the room and perk things up. According to research, they actually breathe...
- Advertisement -

More Articles Like This