32 C
Lagos
Tuesday, February 18, 2020
Advertisement

Heart Rate Measurements of Wearable Monitors Vary by Activity, Not Skin Color

Featured

Here Are the Some of the Most Popular Types of Plastic Surgeries

If you are not very happy with some area of your face or body, then the solution is plastic surgery. There are several sources...

The Importance of Hair Extensions on Your Wedding Day

Your wedding day is approaching soon! What have you planned for your hair do? Think about getting the hair extensions! How can hair extensions make...

Janelle Monáe Says She Got Mercury Poisoning From Her Pescatarian Diet

Janelle Monáe is on the mend after developing mercury poisoning from eating too much fish, she says. The singer shared the news in a...

Experiencing Muscle Aches? Try These X Tips to Relieve the Pain

If you’re an athlete who is used to pushing your body to the limit, you’re probably already familiar with that feeling of intense soreness...

5 Common Symptoms of Foot Discomfort

Experiencing pain in your feet is never pleasant. When your feet hurt, it can affect every aspect of your life. Not only is foot...

Understand Why People Use Drugs

Millions of people in the United States abuse drugs every single year. At any one time, as much as 20% of the American population...

Zimbabwe: Nurse Syndicate Channel Arvs to Black Market

Anti — retroviral (ARV) drugs that are supposed to be dispensed for free by public health institutions are being diverted to the black market...

What Do You Know About Vasectomy?

With the emergence of scarce resources around the world comes the need to check the population growth rate. Different theories have been propounded by...

When You Should Seek Help For Your Child’s Stammer

Stammering in children is incredibly common; kids are just learning a very complicated language that will take years to master and sometimes they make...

How Long Does Nicotine Stay in Your System?

Nicotine is one of the myriads of toxic chemicals that enter your body and lungs when you smoke. This substance can be lethal if...
Avatar
Reporterhttps://healthtian.com
Reporting news worthy and other types content from media outlets from across the web. all rights belong to their respective owners. If you want your content removed email us at legal@kraftysprouts.com with the URL.

Biomedical engineers at Duke University have demonstrated that while different wearable technologies, like smart watches and fitness trackers, can accurately measure heart rate across a variety of skin tones, the accuracy between devices begins to vary wildly when they measure heart rate during different types of everyday activities.

Advertisement

As wearable technologies are increasingly used to monitor patients’ health and collect digital biomarkers for clinical research and health care, this study highlights the need to better understand their accuracy and determine how measurement errors may affect research conclusions and inform medical decisions, according to the researchers.

The study results appear online in the journal NPJ Digital Medicine.

“We started this study because we were seeing some evidence, both in research and anecdotally, that indicated that wearable devices weren’t working as well for people with darker skin tones,” said Jessilyn Dunn, an assistant professor of biomedical engineering at Duke. “People would compare a reading on a chest strap to their smart watch and get different heart rate values.

The companies that manufacture these devices don’t put out any metrics about how well they work across skin tones, so we wanted to collect evidence about how well they work and identify potential circumstances where they may not work well.”

The study enlisted a group of 53 individuals with different skin tones to test the six devices. To establish an accurate baseline, each participant wore an electrocardiogram (ECG) patch to measure their true heart rate during each activity.

Fitness trackers currently measure heart rate using a process called photoplethysmography, or PPG. This involves shining a specific wavelength of light, which usually appears green, from a pulse oximeter sensor on the underside of the device where it touches the skin on the wrist.

As the light illuminates the tissue, the pulse oximeter measures changes in light absorption and the device then uses this data to generate a heart rate measurement.

“Previous research demonstrated that inaccurate PPG heart rate measurements occur up to 15 percent more frequently in dark skin as compared to light skin,” says Dunn. “That’s because darker skin has a higher melanin content, and melanin absorbs the wavelength of light that PPG uses.”

As a second focus of the study, Dunn and her team measured how the devices performed during various types of activity. “There is evidence that people who work at their desk typing all day tend to have worse readings than people who have more stable wrist motion,” Dunn said. “We knew that these devices suffer from motion artifact issues, but it wasn’t clear to what extent.”

Advertisement

Dunn and her lab tested both research-grade and commercial-grade wearable devices to track how diverse skin types, user activity and device type affected the accuracy of heart rate measurements.

They tested commercial devices including the Apple Watch 4, Fitbit Charge 2, Garmin Vivosmart 3 and Xiaomi Midband, and research devices including the Empatica E4 and the Biovotion.

In the first round of the experiment, participants wore the Empatica on one wrist and the Apple Watch on the other. They first sat still to measure their baseline heart rate for four minutes before practicing paced deep breathing for one minute.

Then they walked for five minutes before returning to a seated rest station for two minutes. Finally, they performed a typing task for one minute.

In the second round, the participants repeated these steps while wearing the Fitbit, and in the third round they wore the Garmin, the Xiaomi and the Biovotion.

“Although we did not find statistically significant differences in wearable HR measurement accuracy across skin tones, it doesn’t invalidate past concerns with technology equity,” said graduate student Brinnae Bent, the first author on this study.

“Wearable device software is updated frequently and it appears previous concerns have been addressed in current software versions.”

Although the heart rate measurements were more accurate at rest than during activity, each tested device reported a higher heart rate than the ECG during physical activity across all skin tones.

The team also found that the commercial devices were more accurate at measuring heart rate than the research devices. Maintaining the sensor’s contact with skin can also improve device performance, as the sensor can wiggle around and catch motion artifacts if it’s too loose.

Overall, the Apple Watch demonstrated the most accurate measurements of all tested devices, followed by the Garmin.

Advertisement

“We found that there was a bigger drop in accuracy during activities that involved wrist motion that could introduce motion artifacts, like typing, and we saw a drop in accuracy during deep breathing, which could indicate the devices locking onto cyclic behavior, like breathing, rather than heart rate,” said Dunn.

“We were initially surprised that the commercial devices were more accurate, but they also have huge user bases, so they’re able to use lots of data to clean up their signals and improve their algorithms.

The research wearables are just using raw data, which is important for researchers and clinicians to be aware of.”

The study points the way to improving devices for clinical and research use, she added.

“We want to use these devices to measure digital biomarkers and predict disease outcomes, so if there are disparities in how these devices work we need to identify them,” said Dunn.

“We’ve shown that we have equivalent-enough accuracy that we’re not worried that there is a disparity due to skin tone in these devices, but we’re hoping this puts out the call to companies that make wearables to share more information about how they evaluate the devices so that disparities can be more readily identified and corrected,” Dunn said.

Source: Medical Xpress

More articles

LEAVE A REPLY

Please enter your comment!
Please enter your name here

Trending now

Eating Vaginal Discharge and It’s Health Benefits

For many people, vaginal discharge is a sign that a woman is ready and willing to have sex. Vaginal fluid is a whitish fluid...

Genital Warts: Do They Go Away Naturally? What to Expect?

Human Papilloma Virus is the causative organism for genital warts. The virus is available in various strains, and it can be contacted by many...

Anklet Charms and Hot Wives What Do They Mean?

Women all over the world love to accessorise. From putting on necklaces to wearing makeup and buying the latest trending clothes, women are ready...

Kinky Sex Punishment Ideas You Should Try

Is your submissive being a spoilt little brat? Are you noticing some unwanted behaviour? Do not be dismayed. Sometimes subs can be naughty, and...

Vanilla Sex – Here is Everything You Need to Know

Whenever people talk about Vanilla sex, it is often used to imply plain or conventional sex mostly involving heterosexual couples. But there are a...

How to Increase Appetite in Children Naturally?

Poor appetite is the leading cause of malnutrition in children; every child pass through this phase at a point in their lives, others make...

Skin Rashes: Causes, Symptoms and Effective Home Remedies

Skin rashes are common skin problems experienced by millions of people worldwide; it is characterized by a visible change in the color and texture...

Trypophobia (Fear of Holes) – Symptoms, Causes, and Treatments

Trypophobia (Fear of Holes) is defined as a condition whereby individuals experience an aversion or fear to clusters of tiny holes. This condition is triggered...

Coronavirus – Facts, Types and Symptoms

Coronaviruses are a type of virus that mainly affects the respiratory tract of humans and other mammals. These viruses are associated with pneumonia, common...

Friends